balalajkin

(no subject)

Aug. 16th, 2022 | 10:08 am
From:: balalajkin

Reading Bertrand Russel Why I Am Not a Christian: And Other Essays on Religion and Related Subjects.
There is no other book that aged so badly in its content while being so modern in its influence on the cultural and political landscape.
One may see clearly the faults both inherent in its treatment of historical facts and arising from proclamations and assertions upon which so many educational and legal practices are based.
Bertrand Russel is both an extremely deep and extremely shallow and egotistical thinker, and ingenious insights are immediately followed by grotesquely corny phraseology, befitting bolshevik propagandist, not an academic.
Say, it is difficult to explain that Russel fails to see that the Church's initial impulse was to create a social institution that balances the Roman imperial state apparatus that falls apart as it grows and abandons the early Republican religious principles of universal charity and sanctuary for the feeble and disturbed souls. The primary impulse for the new religion was not fear, but the disturbed consciousness of the disempowered individual, entangled in the imperial bureaucracy. Ameliorating this sense of guilt from forced by the State, yet obviously bad actions, was driving most prominent individuals, i.e. Augustine of Hippo, to seek spiritual comfort of righteous thought and righteous action.

The Church was taking many important functions that the State and its imperial cult simply failed to deliver.

Christianity did not assault sexuality as such, but it restored the Roman republican ideal of steady monogamous marriage - which was tried, but never achieved by the emperors, starting from Augustus. Indeed, this was achieved by abandoning promiscuity and oppressing the adulterers. Some, like Augustine of Hippo, did it voluntarily. Sure, it was done - sometimes - in rather a crude way. Still, it was better than the chaos of divorces, plaguing the Roman empire and an proliferation of the lawyers in the upper class, draining intellectual and material resources from the rest of the society.

Link | view all comments


Reply

From:
(will be screened)
Identity URL: 
имя пользователя:    
Вы должны предварительно войти в LiveJournal.com
 
E-mail для ответов: 
Вы сможете оставлять комментарии, даже если не введете e-mail.
Но вы не сможете получать уведомления об ответах на ваши комментарии!
Внимание: на указанный адрес будет выслано подтверждение.
Username:
Password:
Subject:
No HTML allowed in subject
Message: