ПОЧЕМУ ПУТЛЕРОВСКИЙ СКАЙНЕТ БУДЕТ ТУПЫМ

« previous entry | next entry »
Nov. 28th, 2019 | 08:41 am
mood: peaceful peaceful
music: Jenny Hval -- Six Red Cannas (feat. Vivian Wang, Laura Jean, Félicia Atkinson)

http://crookedtimber.org/2019/11/25/seeing-like-a-finite-state-machine/

So what might a similar analysis say about the marriage of authoritarianism and machine learning? Something like the following, I think. There are two notable problems with machine learning. One – that while it can do many extraordinary things, it is not nearly as universally effective as the mythology suggests. The other is that it can serve as a magnifier for already existing biases in the data. The patterns that it identifies may be the product of the problematic data that goes in, which is (to the extent that it is accurate) often the product of biased social processes. When this data is then used to make decisions that may plausibly reinforce those processes (by singling e.g. particular groups that are regarded as problematic out for particular police attention, leading them to be more liable to be arrested and so on), the bias may feed upon itself.

This is a substantial problem in democratic societies, but it is a problem where there are at least some counteracting tendencies. The great advantage of democracy is its openness to contrary opinions and divergent perspectives. This opens up democracy to a specific set of destabilizing attacks but it also means that there are countervailing tendencies to self-reinforcing biases. When there are groups that are victimized by such biases, they may mobilize against it (although they will find it harder to mobilize against algorithms than overt discrimination). When there are obvious inefficiencies or social, political or economic problems that result from biases, then there will be ways for people to point out these inefficiencies or problems.

These correction tendencies will be weaker in authoritarian societies; in extreme versions of authoritarianism, they may barely even exist. Groups that are discriminated against will have no obvious recourse. Major mistakes may go uncorrected: they may be nearly invisible to a state whose data is polluted both by the means employed to observe and classify it, and the policies implemented on the basis of this data. A plausible feedback loop would see bias leading to error leading to further bias, and no ready ways to correct it. This of course, will be likely to be reinforced by the ordinary politics of authoritarianism, and the typical reluctance to correct leaders, even when their policies are leading to disaster. The flawed ideology of the leader (We must all study Comrade Xi thought to discover the truth!) and of the algorithm (machine learning is magic!) may reinforce each other in highly unfortunate ways.

In short, there is a very plausible set of mechanisms under which machine learning and related techniques may turn out to be a disaster for authoritarianism, reinforcing its weaknesses rather than its strengths, by increasing its tendency to bad decision making, and reducing further the possibility of negative feedback that could help correct against errors. This disaster would unfold in two ways. The first will involve enormous human costs: self-reinforcing bias will likely increase discrimination against out-groups, of the sort that we are seeing against the Uighur today. The second will involve more ordinary self-ramifying errors, that may lead to widespread planning disasters, which will differ from those described in Scott’s account of High Modernism in that they are not as immediately visible, but that may also be more pernicious, and more damaging to the political health and viability of the regime for just that reason.

commemorate | jump from this bridge | Add to Memories


Comments {3}

beefeater

(no subject)

from: [info]beefeater
date: Nov. 28th, 2019 - 06:12 am
commemorate

гитлеровский скайнет

фтп из церна
клауд ВПС на улице Блюхера

Reply


(no subject)

from: anonymous
date: Nov. 28th, 2019 - 08:44 am
commemorate

собственно сссрашка и наебнулась из-за подобных вещей

Reply | Thread


Rise and Shine, Adolph!

(no subject)

from: [info]perfect_kiss
date: Nov. 28th, 2019 - 10:59 am
commemorate

Она еще и по второму кругу наебывается точно по тому же сценарию

Reply | Parent