Сердечно благодарю за коментарий - [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
pet531

[ userinfo | ljr userinfo ]
[ archive | journal archive ]

Links
[Links:| Land of Uz ]

[Dec. 11th, 2016|06:45 pm]
Интересная статья про сионизм Шолема. Цитата не характерная, но яркая:

I never knew Scholem, but, like many, I have a personal story nonetheless.
I was a student at the kabbalistic yeshiva in Jerusalem Yeshivat Ha-Hayyim ve
ha-Shalom from 1982 to 1984 under the tutelage of the renowned kabbalist Rav
Mordecai Attia. I heard that Scholem had died on Feb. 21, 1982, and the funeral
was to commence just as Rav Attia’s daily shiur in Lurianic Kabbalah was to
begin promptly at 3 p.m. I thought about skipping class to attend Scholem’s
funeral but, as I was then still very much in the Haredi world, even though I
instinctively knew it was an important moment, I decided against it. But
perhaps as an act of rebellion, or just curiosity, before class began I turned
to Rav Attia and said, “Did you know Gershom Scholem died today?” He looked at
me dead-pan and responded, “If you mention his name again you will have to
leave the room.” Then he smiled widely through his long beard, opened his book,
looked at me, and said “read.” We never spoke of it again. In retrospect, I
think Scholem would have appreciated Rav Attia’s response.
LinkLeave a comment

Comments:
From:[info]phonomania
Date:December 12th, 2016 - 10:20 am
(Link)
а пачиму пацанчик на фоточки без бороды и пейсов? какой же он сколяр тогда?
From:[info]apkallatu
Date:December 12th, 2016 - 12:33 pm
(Link)
мне тон повествования напомнил известную байку Атийи про Вейля и rien de nouveau ici
From:[info]pet531
Date:December 12th, 2016 - 09:29 pm
(Link)
а что за байка?
From:[info]apkallatu
Date:December 12th, 2016 - 11:52 pm
(Link)
достал откуда-то из кэша, не обессудь

And then we had Andre Weil came and gave a course of lectures here, I think e
nd of my first year, and he'd written this paper about vector bundles and alg
ebraic geometry, vistar, but my relations with him were a bit strained. Actua
lly, what happened was that he gave his course which is in the third term on
developing what lectures he'd given before on algebraic geometry, and Fibre B
undles, and really overlapped a lot with what I was writing up for my Smith's
Prize Essay, and so I was very chuffed - here was this great man giving lect
ures on one of the things that I was working on independently. So I showed hi
m my typescript, first version of my typescript, and was hoping to get some e
ncouragement, you see. He took it away and then he kept it a week or two and
then he gave it back to me and there was no comment, you see, and I was a bit
disappointed. And I looked very carefully and on the sheet, cover sheet we h
ad written on this bit of paper, if you held it up to the light like they do
with all this new electrostatic device or something, you could see some writi
ng. Somebody'd written on another sheet above so it came through, and what it
said was "Rien de Nouveau Ici" and I thought to myself he didn't mean that,
that must have been accidental. But I got to know him subsequently much bette
r when I was a colleague and it's just the kind of thing he would have done.
He wasn't going to tell me to my face that there's nothing new here, but he w
asn't above writing it so I work it out for myself. And you know, in some sen
se it was true. I mean obviously what I was doing was somehow more or less co
ntinuing what he'd been talking about, although I was doing a bit more detail
ed, but still I was a first year graduate student and he was a famous profess
or, and that's not the way you encourage research students. So, you know, if
I'd been a bit sort of less resilient it might have put me off and made me qu
it. But I persisted, but I've never forgotten it.