War rules are cruel just as the war itself. They don’t fit to peace rules at all. Can you imagine any soldier without gun, uniform and food delivered by the army?

Hitler ,Stalin and the others multiple mass murderers has the specific ,brains paralyzing , power over his nation, power which unfortunately survives and still poisons quite many young brains. Nobody wanted to remove them in their times – irrespective of possibilities. Those monsters must had accumulated in themselves the cruelty of all universe !!!!

Socialist scientifically and democratically planning should have reached the result a long time ago. Nobody can’t wait ages for the better life . Since there is still a catastrophe , not a success , let us not to continue this road to nowhere in the name of ideas. Don’t we have a survival instinct ??

The main target for politic leaders (the system doesn’t matter) should be to create conditions for the economy to develop itself. The main target for economic leaders should be to create conditions for the people to develop themselves. Each of us should work for himself/his family – it is the target for the leaders to take advantage of this personal development for the region/country development.

There is a huge amount of Russian people able to work. This is the biggest potential of the country. But ….wasted, due to the sick economy. There are still ( how long?) possibilities to gain money easier and quicker. Radical reforms – what for? To expose the hidden secret – the real size of the catastrophe?

ОК... But still, as soon as the problem of Russia is the rule of scoundrels and the obvious situation of emergency, the historical chance is left shift. The left shift as a means of forced general measures in law-enforcement and economy buildup. The anti-BOLSHEVIK introduction of liberalism was BOLSHEVIK in its nature with "negative" sign. The cure should be similar.
And... Stalin was the person under whom Hitler was defeated and Russia was modernized. The personal cruelty of Stalin is doubtful the further - the more. And - it was condemned by the CPSU 20th Congress. How many times and how long we should duplicate the SPSU decisions, be the Communist tailings?
And I'm not sure that mechanical "work for youself - unlimited" can dramatically contribute to the society. The same doubt had Jesus Christ as he preached to love and treat another as youself. If Christianity is the European ideal, then only Socialism fits it. Christian morality is a collective harmony within Socialism and it is a merely means to COUNTER greed and individualism under capitalism.

Your thinking is very clever and very brilliant, but please remember that so high level of personal value as yours is not a standard – only few percent of population want to see more than the tip of his own nose. That is why the economy model should base on the benefits for the smallest social unit. All of us should work for the society – not only those ,who understand what for.

The problem, you’ve touched is the quality of personal psyche interior. In general only some of us can THINK (!!). Those will have the additional motivation (or maybe the principal one) knowing that his work is mainly for the society and country development. Those can also organize the social help or be a leader of any other noble actions. Those can be the main force of the development. But why does the existing system force them to work instead and for those who - being in good health - prefer the laziness, alcoholism, debauchery or thievery ?

Our personal opinions about any controversial subject and person as Soviet success in Great Patriotic War, Stalin and many others are always subject to the availability of information, the authenticity of this information, the diversity of sources of information, skills of synthesis and rejection of extremes. Unfortunately the historical FACTS are still not the same for all. That is why Stalin may still be viewed by different persons as a cruel murderer or as a great savior of the country.

the Holy Gospel teaches: He who doesn't work - doesn't eat. The BOLSHEVIKS tried to bring the principle into life by anti-parasitism laws and a system of GULag... "Arbeit macht frei"... It's a scandal, but it's true even in America.